by Printer Brands
Ink
Toner
Label Tapes
Label Paper Roll
Ribbon
Label Printers
Office Supplies
Other
Choosing between HP147A (W1470A) and HP147X (W1470X) toner cartridges for your HP LaserJet Enterprise printer? This comprehensive guide breaks down the key differences in page yield, cost-per-page, and compatibility to help you make an informed decision. We’ll also explore how compatible cartridges can offer significant savings without compromising quality, helping you optimise your printing budget while maintaining professional results.
HP147A vs HP147X: Specifications Comparison
Understanding the technical differences between HP147A and HP147X toner cartridges is essential for making the right choice for your printing needs. The primary distinction lies in their page yield capacity, directly impacting your printing costs and cartridge replacement frequency.
HP147A vs HP147X: Complete Toner Cartridge Comparison Guide
HP147A (standard) and HP147X (high-yield) toner cartridges
| Specification | HP147A (W1470A) | HP147X (W1470X) |
| Page Yield (ISO/IEC 19752) | 10,500 pages | 25,200 pages |
| Original Cartridge Price (Singapore) | S$160.90 | S$268.90 |
| Cost Per Page (Original) | 1.53 cents | 1.07 cents |
| Compatible Cartridge Price (Singapore) | S$99.90 | S$149.90 |
| Cost Per Page (Compatible) | 0.95 cents | 0.59 cents |
| Package Dimensions | 14.96 x 7.09 x 10.63 in | 14.96 x 7.09 x 11.30 in |
| Package Weight | 4.02 lbs | 5.96 lbs |
| Print Technology | Laser | Laser |
| Operating Temperature Range | 50°F to 91°F | 50°F to 91°F |
| Operating Humidity Range | 10% to 80% RH | 10% to 80% RH |
| Warranty | HP Premium Protection | HP Premium Protection |
Understanding Page Yield and ISO/IEC 19752 Standard
Page yield refers to the number of pages a toner cartridge can print before needing replacement. The ISO/IEC 19752 standard provides a consistent method for measuring toner cartridge yield for monochrome laser printers, ensuring fair comparisons between different cartridges.
What is ISO/IEC 19752? This international standard specifies a method for determining the page yield of toner cartridges for monochrome laser printers. Testing involves printing standard documents with 5% page coverage until the cartridge reaches end-of-life. This standardised approach allows for fair comparisons between different cartridge models.
5% page coverage (ISO standard) vs. typical business document coverage
The HP147X offers 140% more pages than the HP147A (25,200 vs. 10,500), making it significantly more efficient for high-volume printing environments. While the initial purchase price is higher, the cost-per-page is substantially lower, providing better long-term value.
Cost Analysis: HP147A vs HP147X
When comparing the HP147A and HP147X toner cartridges, cost-effectiveness becomes critical. Let’s analyse each option’s total cost of ownership and long-term savings potential.
Cost comparison between HP147A and HP147X for 50,000 printed pages
Cost-Per-Page Calculation
Cost-per-page is calculated by dividing the cartridge price by the page yield. This metric provides a clear picture of the actual printing cost over time:
HP147A Cost-Per-Page
Original: S$160.90 ÷ 10,500 pages = 1.53 cents per page
Compatible: S$99.90 ÷ 10,500 pages = 0.95 cents per page
HP147X Cost-Per-Page
Original: S$268.90 ÷ 25,200 pages = 1.07 cents per page
Compatible: S$149.90 ÷ 25,200 pages = 0.59 cents per page
Long-Term Cost Comparison
To print 50,000 pages, you would need:
| Cartridge Type | Number of Cartridges Needed | Total Cost | Savings vs. HP147A Original |
| HP147A Original | 5 cartridges | S$804.50 | – |
| HP147X Original | 2 cartridges | S$537.80 | S$266.70 (33%) |
| HP147A Compatible | 5 cartridges | S$499.50 | S$305.00 (38%) |
| HP147X Compatible | 2 cartridges | S$299.80 | S$504.70 (63%) |
Calculate Your Printing Savings
Find out how much you could save by switching to high-yield compatible cartridges for your specific printing volume.
Calculate SavingsSustainability Benefits of HP147X High-Yield Cartridges
Beyond cost savings, the HP147X high-yield cartridge offers significant environmental benefits compared to the standard HP147A. Using fewer cartridges means less waste and a reduced carbon footprint.
Environmental impact comparison: HP147X requires fewer cartridges for the same print volume
Sustainability Advantages of HP147X
- 140% more pages per cartridge means fewer replacements
- Reduced packaging waste
- Lower transportation emissions
- Less frequent shipping and handling
- Fewer cartridges to recycle or dispose of
Environmental Impact for 100,000 Pages
Printing 100,000 pages would require:
- HP147A: 10 cartridges
- HP147X: 4 cartridges
- Waste Reduction: 60% less cartridge waste
- Packaging Reduction: 60% less packaging material
Sustainability Tip: Both HP original and compatible cartridges can be recycled. Check with your local recycling program or return to the manufacturer for proper disposal.
Compatible Printers for HP147A and HP147X
Both the HP147A and HP147X toner cartridges are compatible with the same range of HP LaserJet Enterprise printers. Before purchasing, verify that your specific printer model is supported.
HP LaserJet Enterprise M611 series printer – compatible with both HP147A and HP147X
| Printer Series | Compatible Models | HP147A Compatible | HP147X Compatible |
| HP LaserJet Enterprise M610 Series | M610n, M610dn | ✓ | ✓ |
| HP LaserJet Enterprise M611 Series | M611dn, M611x | ✓ | ✓ |
| HP LaserJet Enterprise M612 Series | M612dn, M612x | ✓ | ✓ |
| HP LaserJet Enterprise MFP M634 Series | M634dn, M634z, M634h | ✓ | ✓ |
| HP LaserJet Enterprise MFP M635 Series | M635fht, M635h, M635z | ✓ | ✓ |
| HP LaserJet Enterprise MFP M636 Series | M636fh, M636z | ✓ | ✓ |
Important: While both cartridges work with the same printer models, they cannot be used interchangeably in printers configured for a specific cartridge type. Check your printer’s current configuration before purchasing.
Shop Compatible HP 147A/X Toner Cartridges
Save up to 59% on your printing costs with high-quality compatible HP 147A and HP 147X toner cartridges from InkWorld.
Check CompatibilityOriginal vs. Compatible HP147A and HP147X Cartridges
When choosing between original HP cartridges and compatible alternatives, several factors come into play, including cost, quality, and warranty considerations.
Original HP147X cartridge (left) compared to compatible alternative (right)
| Feature | Original HP Cartridges | Compatible Cartridges |
| HP147A Price (Singapore) | S$160.90 | S$99.90 |
| HP147X Price (Singapore) | S$268.90 | S$149.90 |
| Cost Savings | – | 38-44% |
| Page Yield | HP147A: 10,500 HP147X: 25,200 | HP147A: 10,500 HP147X: 25,200 |
| Print Quality | Excellent | Very Good to Excellent |
| Warranty | HP Premium Protection | Varies by manufacturer (typically 1-3 years) |
| Printer Warranty Impact | No impact | Protected by the Singapore Consumer Protection Act |
| Manufacturing Standards | HP proprietary | ISO-9001 certified (quality varies by manufacturer) |
Advantages of Compatible Cartridges
Advantages
- Significant cost savings (38-44%)
- Same page yield as original cartridges
- Manufactured to ISO-9001 standards
- Many include lifetime printer guarantees
- Environmentally friendly (remanufactured options available)
- Protected by Singapore’s Consumer Protection Act
Considerations
- Quality can vary between manufacturers
- May occasionally require printer recalibration
- Some printers may display “non-genuine cartridge” messages
- Warranty support varies by supplier
- Limited availability for the newest printer models
Singapore Consumer Protection (Fair Trading) Act
Singapore’s Consumer Protection (Fair Trading) Act protects consumers who use compatible cartridges. Under this legislation, manufacturers cannot void your printer warranty simply because you used a compatible cartridge. The warranty can only be voided if the compatible cartridge caused damage to the printer.
“A manufacturer cannot condition consumer warranty coverage on the consumer’s use of any article or service identified by brand, trade, or corporate name unless provided free of charge under the warranty.”
Try Compatible Cartridges Risk-Free
Experience the quality and savings of compatible HP147A and HP147X cartridges with our satisfaction guarantee.
Shop Compatible Cartridges
HP147A and HP147X Installation Guide
Installing HP147A or HP147X toner cartridges is straightforward. Follow these steps to ensure proper installation and optimal performance.
Step-by-step installation of HP147A/HP147X toner cartridge
Installation Steps
- Prepare the printer
Turn on your printer and wait until it’s idle. Open the front cover by pressing the release button.
- Remove the old cartridge.
Grasp the old toner cartridge by its handle and pull it straight out. Place it aside for recycling.
- Unpack the new cartridge.
Remove the new HP147A or HP147X cartridge from its packaging. Be careful not to touch the green imaging drum or any contacts.
- Prepare the cartridge
Gently rock the cartridge back and forth 5-6 times to distribute the toner evenly inside.
- Remove the protective strip.
Pull the orange tab to remove the protective sealing strip from the cartridge.
- Insert the new cartridge.
Align the cartridge with the tracks inside the printer and slide it in until it clicks into place.
- Close the printer
Close the front cover firmly until it latches. The printer will initialise the new cartridge.
- Print a test page
Print a test page to ensure proper installation and print quality.
Important: Always handle toner cartridges using their plastic handles. Avoid touching the green imaging drum or metal contacts, as oils from your skin can damage these sensitive components.
Troubleshooting Common HP147A and HP147X Issues
Even with proper installation, you may occasionally encounter issues with your HP147A or HP147X toner cartridges. Here are solutions to the most common problems.
Common print quality issues and their solutions
Poor Print Quality or Faded Prints
Cause: Low toner, uneven toner distribution, or printer settings.
Solution:
- Remove the cartridge and gently rock it side to side to redistribute toner
- Check printer settings for toner density or EconoMode settings
- Clean the printer’s interior with a dry, lint-free cloth
- If problems persist, the cartridge may need replacement
“Non-Genuine Cartridge” Message
Cause: The printer detects a compatible cartridge instead of an original HP cartridge.
Solution:
- Press “OK” or “Continue” to bypass the message (this won’t affect printing)
- For persistent messages, check printer settings for “Cartridge Policy” and change it to “Off” if it is available.
- Update printer firmware to the latest version
Note: This message is informational and doesn’t indicate a problem with the cartridge.
Streaks or Lines on Printed Pages
Cause: Debris on the imaging drum, damaged drum, or printer issues.
Solution:
- Print a cleaning page (available in the printer maintenance menu)
- Check for and remove any paper debris in the paper path
- Remove and inspect the cartridge for damage
- If using a compatible cartridge, try a different brand
Printer Not Recognising Cartridge
Cause: Contact issues, damaged chip, or incompatible cartridge.
Solution:
- Remove and reinsert the cartridge, ensuring it clicks into place
- Clean the cartridge contacts with a dry, lint-free cloth
- Power cycle the printer (turn off, unplug for 30 seconds, plug in, turn on)
- Verify that the cartridge is the correct model for your printer
Toner Leakage
Cause: Damaged cartridge or improper handling.
Solution:
- Remove the cartridge carefully and check for damage
- Clean any spilt toner with a cool, damp cloth (avoid hot water)
- Replace the cartridge if damaged
- Contact the supplier for warranty replacement if applicable
Warning: Do not use a vacuum cleaner to clean up toner unless it is designed explicitly for toner particles.
Need Technical Support?
Our technical support team is available to help resolve any issues with your HP147A or HP147X cartridges.
Contact Support
Finding a Reliable Compatible Cartridge Supplier
When purchasing compatible HP147A or HP147X cartridges, choosing a reputable supplier ensures quality and reliability. Here are the key factors to consider when selecting a supplier in Singapore.
InkWorld Singapore offers a wide selection of compatible HP toner cartridges.
What Makes a Reliable Supplier?
Quality Indicators
- ISO-9001 certified manufacturing
- Satisfaction guarantee or money-back policy
- Detailed product specifications
- Transparent page yield information
- Clear warranty terms
Service Indicators
- Responsive customer support
- Technical assistance availability
- Fast shipping options
- Easy returns process
- Positive customer reviews
InkWorld: A Trusted Compatible Cartridge Supplier
InkWorld has established itself as a reliable supplier of compatible printer cartridges in Singapore. It offers over 1,000 cartridge models across 19 popular brands, including HP, Canon, Epson, and Brother.
“I’ve been using InkWorld’s compatible HP147X cartridges for our office printers for over a year. The print quality is indistinguishable from the originals, and we’ve saved thousands of dollars. Their customer service is excellent, and delivery is always prompt.”
Shop InkWorld’s Compatible HP147A and HP147X Cartridges
Experience premium quality at affordable prices with InkWorld’s compatible toner cartridges, backed by a satisfaction guarantee.
Shop NowFrequently Asked Questions About HP147A vs HP147X
Here are answers to the most common questions about HP147A and HP147X toner cartridges to help you make an informed decision.
What is the main difference between HP147A and HP147X toner cartridges?
The primary difference is page yield. The HP147X is a high-yield cartridge that prints approximately 25,200 pages, while the standard HP147A prints about 10,500 pages. The HP147X offers 140% more prints per cartridge, making it more economical for high-volume printing despite its higher initial cost.
Will using compatible HP147A or HP147X cartridges void my printer warranty?
No, using compatible cartridges will not automatically void your printer warranty. Under Singapore’s Consumer Protection (Fair Trading) Act, manufacturers cannot void warranties simply because you used compatible cartridges. The warranty can only be voided if the compatible cartridge caused damage to the printer.
How do I know when to replace my HP147A or HP147X toner cartridge?
HP printers typically display a “Toner Low” message when approximately 10-15% of toner remains. You’ll see a “Replace Toner” message when the cartridge is nearly empty. For optimal print quality, it’s recommended to have a replacement cartridge available when you see the “Toner Low” message, but you can continue printing until quality deteriorates.
Can I use HP147A and HP147X interchangeably in my printer?
Yes, both cartridges are physically compatible with the same printer models. However, if your printer was initially configured with a specific cartridge type, you might need to update settings when switching between models. Both will work in the compatible printers listed in this article.
How long do HP147A and HP147X toner cartridges last before expiring?
Unopened HP toner cartridges typically have a shelf life of 2.5 years from manufacture. Compatible cartridges usually have similar shelf lives. Once installed, the cartridge should be used within 6 months for optimal print quality. The manufacturing date is printed on the cartridge packaging.
What is the print quality difference between original and compatible HP147A/HP147X cartridges?
High-quality compatible cartridges from reputable suppliers produce print results virtually indistinguishable from original HP cartridges. Premium compatible cartridges use high-grade toner powder and components that meet or exceed OEM specifications. However, quality can vary between manufacturers, so choosing a reputable supplier is important.
How much can I save using compatible HP147X instead of original HP cartridges?
Compatible HP147X cartridges can save approximately 44% compared to original HP147X cartridges. This can translate to thousands of dollars in savings annually for high-volume printing environments. For example, printing 100,000 pages would cost approximately S$1,074 with original HP147X cartridges versus S$599 with compatible alternatives.
Are HP147A and HP147X toner cartridges available in colours other than black?
No, HP147A and HP147X are exclusively black (monochrome) toner cartridges designed for text and grayscale printing. They are not available in colour variants as they are specifically designed for HP’s monochrome LaserJet Enterprise printer series.
How do I properly store unused HP147A or HP147X toner cartridges?
Unopened toner cartridges in their original packaging should be stored in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. The ideal temperature range is 10-32°C (50-90°F), with humidity between 20-80%. Avoid storing near solvents, motors, or electronic equipment that produce ozone. Do not store cartridges on their ends or upside down.
What should I do with the HP147A or HP147X toner cartridges I use?
Both original and compatible toner cartridges should be recycled rather than disposed of in regular waste. You can return original HP cartridges in Singapore through HP’s Planet Partners program. Many compatible cartridge suppliers also offer recycling programs. Alternatively, you can use designated e-waste recycling points throughout Singapore.
Conclusion: Choosing Between HP147A and HP147X
When deciding between HP147A and HP147X toner cartridges, consider your printing volume, budget, and long-term costs. The HP147X offers superior value for high-volume printing environments with its 140% higher page yield and lower cost-per-page. The HP147A may be sufficient for occasional printing needs with its lower initial purchase price.
Compatible cartridges provide a cost-effective alternative to original HP cartridges, offering 38-44% savings without significantly compromising print quality. When purchasing compatible cartridges, choose reputable suppliers like InkWorld that offer quality guarantees and excellent customer support.
Remember that both original and compatible cartridges are protected under Singapore’s Consumer Protection (Fair Trading) Act, ensuring that using compatible options won’t void your printer warranty unless they cause actual damage to your printer.
Ready to Save on Your Printing Costs?
Explore our high-quality HP147A and HP147X compatible toner cartridges and start saving today.
Shop & Save 147A/147X
