by Printer Brands
Ink
Toner
Label Tapes
Label Paper Roll
Ribbon
Label Printers
Office Supplies
Other
Choosing between HP 151A and HP 151X toner cartridges can significantly impact printing costs and efficiency. These monochrome toner cartridges for HP LaserJet Pro printers differ in page yield, price, and value proposition. This comprehensive guide compares their specifications, cost-per-page, compatibility, and sustainability benefits to help you make an informed decision for your Singapore business or home office.
HP 151A vs HP 151X: Detailed Specifications Comparison
Understanding the key differences between HP 151A (W1510A) and HP 151X (W1510X) toner cartridges helps you select the right option for your printing needs. Both cartridges deliver high-quality monochrome prints but differ in several important aspects.
HP 151A vs HP 151X Toner Cartridges: Cost, Yield & Compatibility
Key Specifications and Differences
The table below highlights the main technical specifications and differences between Singapore’s standard-capacity HP 151A and high-capacity HP 151X toner cartridges.
| Specification | HP 151A (W1510A) | HP 151X (W1510X) |
| Page Yield (ISO/IEC 19752) | 3,050 pages | 9,700 pages |
| Singapore Retail Price (SGD) | S$176.80 | S$339.00 |
| Cost Per Page | S$0.058 | S$0.035 |
| Print Technology | Laser | Laser |
| Toner Color | Black | Black |
| Relative Capacity | Standard | 3.18x higher than standard |
Understanding Page Yield and ISO/IEC 19752 Standards
Page yield refers to the number of pages a toner cartridge can print before requiring replacement. The ISO/IEC 19752 standard provides a consistent methodology for measuring toner cartridge yield for monochrome laser printers.
The ISO/IEC 19752 testing procedure involves printing standard documents with 5% page coverage until the cartridge reaches end-of-life. This standardised approach allows for fair comparisons between different toner cartridges.
It’s important to note that actual page yields may vary based on several factors:
- Content type (text-heavy vs. graphics-heavy documents)
- Print density settings
- Environmental conditions
- Printing frequency and patterns
- Printer model and maintenance
Compatible Printers for HP 151A and HP 151X Toner Cartridges
Both HP 151A and HP 151X toner cartridges are compatible with the same range of HP LaserJet Pro printer models. However, the choice between standard and high-capacity cartridges should be based on your printing volume.
HP LaserJet Pro Printer Models Compatible with HP 151A/X
| Printer Series | Specific Models | Recommended Cartridge |
| HP LaserJet Pro 4003 Series | 4003dw, 4003w | HP 151A for low volume HP 151X for high volume |
| HP LaserJet Pro MFP 4103 Series | 4103fdw, 4103fdn | HP 151A for low volume HP 151X for high volume |
| HP LaserJet Pro 4001-4008 Series | All models in the range | HP 151A for low volume HP 151X for high volume |
| HP LaserJet Pro MFP 4101-4108 Series | All models in the range | HP 151A for low volume HP 151X for high volume |
Choosing the Right Cartridge Based on Printer Usage
Recommended for HP 151A (Standard Capacity)
- Home offices with light printing needs (under 500 pages monthly)
- Small businesses with occasional document printing
- Environments where print quality is needed but volume is low
- Users with budget constraints for initial purchase
Recommended for HP 151X (High Capacity)
- Medium to large businesses with regular printing (1,000+ pages monthly)
- Shared office printers serving multiple users
- Environments requiring minimal cartridge changes
- Users focused on long-term cost efficiency
Cost Analysis: HP 151A vs HP 151X Toner Cartridges
While the HP 151X has a higher upfront cost than the HP 151A, its larger page yield results in a lower cost-per-page, making it more economical for high-volume printing environments.
Cost-Per-Page Calculation
Cost-per-page is calculated by dividing the cartridge price by its page yield. This metric helps determine the true cost of printing and allows for fair comparisons between different cartridge options.
| Cartridge Model | Singapore Price (SGD) | Page Yield | Cost-Per-Page | Savings Per Page vs. 151A |
| HP 151A (W1510A) | S$176.80 | 3,050 | S$0.058 | – |
| HP 151X (W1510X) | S$339.00 | 9,700 | S$0.035 | S$0.023 (39.7%) |
Long-Term Cost Savings with HP 151X
The table below illustrates the long-term cost savings of using the high-capacity HP 151X over the standard HP 151A for different monthly print volumes.
| Monthly Print Volume | Annual Cost with HP 151A | Annual Cost with HP 151X | Annual Savings with HP 151X |
| 500 pages | S$348.00 | S$210.00 | S$138.00 |
| 1,000 pages | S$696.00 | S$420.00 | S$276.00 |
| 2,000 pages | S$1,392.00 | S$840.00 | S$552.00 |
Calculate Your Printing Savings
Find out how much you could save by switching to high-capacity HP 151X toner cartridges based on your specific printing volume.
Calculate Your SavingsSustainability Benefits of High-Capacity HP 151X Toner
Beyond cost savings, the high-capacity HP 151X toner cartridge offers significant sustainability advantages compared to using multiple standard-capacity HP 151A cartridges.
Environmental Impact Comparison
Using HP 151A (Standard Capacity)
- Requires approximately 3.2 cartridges to print 9,700 pages
- More packaging waste from multiple cartridges
- Increased shipping and transportation emissions
- More frequent cartridge replacements and disposal
Using HP 151X (High Capacity)
- Single cartridge prints 9,700 pages
- Reduced packaging waste (up to 68% less)
- Lower shipping and transportation emissions
- Fewer cartridge replacements and less frequent disposal
By choosing the high-capacity HP 151X toner cartridge, you’re saving money and reducing your environmental footprint. For businesses with sustainability goals, this is an important consideration alongside cost-effectiveness.
Original vs Compatible HP 151A and HP 151X Toner Cartridges
While original HP toner cartridges offer guaranteed quality and reliability, compatible alternatives from reputable suppliers can provide significant cost savings without compromising print quality.
Price and Value Comparison
The table below compares original HP toner cartridges with compatible alternatives in Singapore.
| Cartridge Type | Price (SGD) | Page Yield | Cost-Per-Page | Savings vs Original |
| Original HP 151A | S$176.80 | 3,050 | S$0.058 | – |
| Compatible HP 151A | S$75.00 | 3,050 | S$0.025 | S$0.033 (57%) |
| Original HP 151X | S$339.00 | 9,700 | S$0.035 | – |
| Compatible HP 151X | S$135.00 | 9,700 | S$0.014 | S$0.021 (60%) |
Advantages of Compatible Toner Cartridges
Advantages
- Significant cost savings (up to 60% less than original HP cartridges)
- Comparable page yields to original cartridges
- Many include recycling programs for environmental sustainability
- Often come with warranties and quality guarantees
- Compatible with the same printer models as the original cartridges
Considerations
- Quality can vary between manufacturers
- Some printers may display “non-genuine cartridge” messages
- Potential for slightly different print quality in high-detail images
- Warranty concerns (though legally protected in Singapore)
- Requires research to find reputable suppliers
Consumer Protection in Singapore
Under Singapore’s Consumer Protection (Fair Trading) Act, printer manufacturers cannot void your warranty simply for using compatible cartridges. Your printer remains protected as long as the compatible cartridge doesn’t damage it.
Using compatible cartridges alone is insufficient grounds for warranty denial under Singapore consumer protection laws. Manufacturers must prove that the compatible cartridge directly caused damage to the printer.
Shop Compatible HP 151A/X Toner Cartridges
Save up to 67% on your printing costs with high-quality compatible HP 151A and HP 151X toner cartridges from InkWorld.
Shop NowInkWorld: Singapore’s Trusted Compatible Cartridge Supplier
InkWorld has established itself as a leading supplier of compatible printer cartridges in Singapore, offering reliable alternatives to original HP toner cartridges at competitive prices.
About InkWorld
- Over 15 years of experience in the Singapore printer supplies market
- Extensive inventory of more than 1,000 cartridge models for 19 popular printer brands
- ISO 9001-certified manufacturing processes
- Comprehensive 12-month warranty on all compatible cartridges
- Multiple retail locations across Singapore with next-day delivery options
Quality Assurance Process
InkWorld’s compatible HP 151A and HP 151X toner cartridges undergo rigorous testing to ensure performance comparable to original HP cartridges:
- Component inspection for structural integrity
- Assembly verification to ensure proper fit and function
- Print quality assessment for clarity and consistency
- Page yield verification to confirm stated capacity
- Printer compatibility testing with designated models
Step-by-Step Installation Guide for HP 151A and HP 151X Toner Cartridges
Installing HP 151A or HP 151X toner cartridges in your HP LaserJet Pro printer is a straightforward process. Follow these steps to ensure proper installation and optimal performance.
- Prepare the printer: Turn off your HP LaserJet Pro printer and allow it to cool for 30 minutes if it has been in use.
- Open the printer: Open the front cover of your printer to access the toner cartridge compartment.
- Remove old cartridge: If replacing an existing cartridge, grasp it by the middle handle and pull it straight out. Avoid tilting to prevent toner spills.
- Prepare new cartridge: Remove the new HP 151A or HP 151X cartridge from its packaging. Gently rock it back and forth 5-6 times to distribute the toner evenly.
- To remove the sealing tape, pull the orange tab to remove it completely. Pull straight out in one smooth motion.
- Insert new cartridge: Align it with the guides inside the printer and slide it in until it clicks into place.
- Close the printer: Close the front cover securely.
- Test print: Turn on the printer, wait for it to initialise, and print a test page to verify proper installation.
Important: Never expose the toner cartridge to direct light for extended periods, as this can damage the sensitive drum. Complete the installation process promptly after removing the cartridge from its protective packaging.
Troubleshooting Common Issues with HP 151A and HP 151X Toner Cartridges
Even with proper installation, you may occasionally encounter issues with your HP 151A or HP 151X toner cartridges. Here are solutions to common problems.
Print Quality Issues
| Issue | Possible Causes | Solution |
| Faded prints | Low toner level, print density setting too low | Gently rock the cartridge to redistribute toner. In printer properties, adjust print density settings. Replace the cartridge if it is nearing the end of its life. |
| Streaks or lines | Debris on the drum, damaged cartridge. | Remove the cartridge and check for damage. Clean the printer interior with a dry, lint-free cloth. If damaged, replace the cartridge. |
| Spotty prints | Toner clumps, paper quality issues | Try higher-quality paper. Gently rock the cartridge to break up toner clumps. Run the printer’s cleaning cycle. |
| Ghost images | Drum not discharging properly, wrong paper type setting | Verify that the paper type settings match the media being used. Run the printer’s calibration routine. Replace the cartridge if the issue persists. |
Cartridge Recognition Issues
Original HP Cartridges
- Error message: Remove and reinstall the cartridge. Ensure protective tape is completely removed.
- Not recognised: Clean gold contacts on the cartridge with a dry, lint-free cloth. Restart the printer.
- Premature “low toner” warning: Override in printer settings or continue printing until quality degrades.
Compatible Cartridges
- “Non-genuine cartridge” message: Normal for compatible cartridges. Press “OK” or “Continue” to proceed.
- Not recognised: Check if the cartridge chip is properly seated. If the issue persists, contact the supplier for a replacement.
- Firmware issues: Some printer firmware updates may affect compatibility. Contact the supplier for an updated cartridge.
If using compatible cartridges, be aware that some HP printer firmware updates may affect cartridge recognition. Contact your cartridge supplier for assistance if you experience sudden compatibility issues after a firmware update.
Frequently Asked Questions About HP 151A and HP 151X Toner Cartridges.
Here are answers to common questions about HP 151A and HP 151X toner cartridges, compatibility, and performance.
What is the difference between HP 151A and HP 151X toner cartridges?
The main difference is page yield. The HP 151A (standard capacity) yields approximately 3,050 pages, while the HP 151X (high capacity) yields about 9,700 pages. The HP 151X offers a lower cost-per-page but has a higher upfront cost.
Are HP 151A and HP 151X toner cartridges compatible with the same printers?
Yes, both cartridges are compatible with the same HP LaserJet Pro printer models, including the 4003 and 4103 series and others in the 4001-4008 and 4101-4108 ranges.
How do I know when to replace my HP 151A or HP 151X toner cartridge?
Your printer will display a “Low Toner” message when approximately 10% of toner remains. You can continue printing until you notice a degradation in print quality, which typically appears as fading or uneven printing.
Are the compatible HP 151A and HP 151X cartridges safe for my printer?
Quality compatible cartridges from reputable suppliers like InkWorld are designed to work safely with your printer. They undergo testing to ensure compatibility and performance. Under Singapore’s Consumer Protection laws, using compatible cartridges alone cannot void your printer warranty.
What is the shelf life of HP 151A and HP 151X toner cartridges?
Unopened HP toner cartridges typically have a shelf life of 2.5 years from manufacture. Once installed, the cartridge should be used within 6 months for optimal print quality.
Can I recycle HP 151A and HP 151X toner cartridges in Singapore?
Yes, HP operates a cartridge recycling program in Singapore. Many compatible cartridge suppliers, including InkWorld, offer take-back programs for recycling used cartridges.
Why does my printer show “non-genuine cartridge” with compatible HP 151A/X cartridges?
This is normal behaviour when using compatible cartridges. Your printer can detect that the cartridge is not an original HP product. Simply press “OK” or “Continue” to proceed with printing. This message does not indicate any problem with the cartridge.
Is there a print quality difference between original and compatible HP 151A/X cartridges?
High-quality compatible cartridges produce results similar to those of original HP cartridges for standard business documents. For specialised printing needs like high-resolution graphics or photos, original HP cartridges may offer slightly better quality.
How can I maximise the life of my HP 151A or HP 151X toner cartridge?
To extend cartridge life: use draft mode for internal documents, print in grayscale instead of black, enable duplex printing to save paper, and remove the cartridge properly when not using the printer for extended periods.
Where can I buy genuine and compatible HP 151A and HP 151X toner cartridges in Singapore?
Original HP cartridges are available from HP’s online store, authorised retailers, and electronics stores. Compatible cartridges can be purchased from specialised suppliers like InkWorld, which has physical stores across Singapore and an online shop with delivery options.
Conclusion: Making the Right Choice Between HP 151A and HP 151X
When choosing between HP 151A and HP 151X toner cartridges for your HP LaserJet Pro printer, consider your printing volume, budget constraints, and long-term cost efficiency.
For low-volume users printing less than 500 pages monthly, the standard-capacity HP 151A offers a lower initial investment. However, for medium to high-volume printing environments, the high-capacity HP 151X provides significantly better value with its lower cost-per-page and reduced environmental impact.
Compatible alternatives from reputable suppliers like InkWorld offer substantial cost savings for both cartridge models while maintaining comparable print quality and reliability. These options are desirable for cost-conscious businesses and home users in Singapore.
Regardless of which option you choose, proper installation and maintenance will help maximise cartridge life and ensure optimal print quality for your HP LaserJet Pro printer.
Browse InkWorld’s HP 151A/X Toner Collection
Find the perfect toner solution for your HP printer with InkWorld’s extensive collection of compatible cartridges at competitive prices.
Shop 151A/X Toner Collection
